Specialists’ insight

  • 11 April 2021
  • 11:51
  • 6 Viewpoint
  • 799 View
  • Article Rating
Specialists’ insight

Mr. Jafari was one of our outstanding colleagues and valuable human resources that we have had in IREMA. He worked with the power exchange bureau of Iran Grid Management Company, Deputy of Electricity Market. He is now working as Electricity Market Analyst in the Balancing and Settlement Code Administrator in England. IREMA representatives have asked the following questions from Mr. Jafari. We would like to share it here and hope it would be beneficial for the IREMA audiences.

Due to your great reputation in the industry of energy markets, Iran Electricity Market (IREMA) would be very pleased if you could answer the following questions. The questions are designed to clear the issue for the worldwide and IREMA audiences.  

If we categorize the trading environment to spot markets, centrally managed future and forward markets (power exchange), and the bilateral contracts:

  1. Within the electricity market that you are currently engaged with/you have conducted research about,
    1. Should the parties that trades based on the bilateral contracts frame work go through procedures of the power exchange for bilateral trading or they could make it completely independent?

It is absolutely up to the market participants to decide. In terms of whether or not they have the option to trade through bilateral contracts or power exchanges (Nordpool, Epex, …) they are totally provided with this flexibility to go through either and there is no obligatory regulation to require them behave in favor of one. It is by any means their discretion to decide.

  1. Could you compare the volume of trades in the power exchange and the bilateral contracts with respect to the total supplied load?

As in all electricity markets around the globe, market participants in England can trade electricity through bilateral contracts, power exchanges or the spot/balancing market. The majority of the energy is traded bilaterally in advance. Bilateral contracts and power exchanges constitute up to and sometimes above 70% of the total “energy consumption/generation”. I am afraid I cannot break down the volume more though the share of bilateral contract in this mix is to some extent higher than power exchanges. The point is, the role of the energy and power exchanges is note solely offering direct trade platforms. They provide financial facilities and tools for energy businesses to help them hedge bilateral or spot commitments. It is these financial mechanisms where they show their advantages.

As you are aware of, the topology of the transmission lines is considered in the day ahead markets enabling the market operator to simulate the closest economic efficiency in the real-time. In such cases:

  1. If the transmission system experiences a failure that will not be cleared in long term (with respect to the day-ahead market time scopes):
    1. Some power plants that may earn profit due in no small part to this failure. How these kinds of power plants would be treated?
    2. Some power plants that may lose their opportunity to sell their energy due in no small part to this failure. How these kinds of power plants would be treated? 
    3. The consumer side may also be imposed with higher electricity prices. How they will be compensated against this happening?
    4. Are there any penalizing/remuneration mechanisms to incentivize TSOs reduce the outage time?
    5. Is there any insurance mechanism to compensate the generation/ consumption side against the transmission system outages?

In GB balancing arrangements, the market participants’ generation or demand are evaluated against their commitments. Day ahead trades are not tied with the network topology and constraints though balancing mechanisms are. All trades’ data, regardless of the trading type, whether it’s been through bilateral, exchanges, etc. are fed into the balancing arrangements. The market participants are obliged to stick to the volumes they have contracted for in advance. If they deviate from their commitments they are exposed to the System Price, i.e. the price of balancing the system for System Operator. This could be a negative or a positive price. Along with the contracts volume that are fed into the system, the System Operator (SO) also receives Bid/Offer prices from market participants prior to the settlement period (which is half an hour in England). These are prices market participants are willing to pay or get paid should the SO asks them to deviate from their contracted volume. At the end of the day, the settlement system uses the contracted volumes, the metered volumes and the Bid/Offer used by SO, to determine the system price.

If a market participant has been deviated from their commitment in a settlement period, they must pay or get paid the system price (per MWh of the deviation). If deviations were to maintain the system security, i.e. the SO asksed them to increase/decrease their generation/consumption, they are considered “SO-flagged” actions and are exempt from system price.

Electricity market encountered with inherent challenges of non-convexities resulted from the stop-start costs, minimum power generation constraints and on-off status of the generation units. Due to these non-convexities, the prices were derived with some assumptions and it requires a great attention to the cost recovery and market efficiency characteristics of the electricity market design to be preserved under these assumptions.

  1.  How the non-convexities of the market clearing problem (such as start-stop costs) are handled in the electricity markets you have engaged with?
    1. from the optimization problem and driving the prices point of view
    2. from the payments point of view and cost recovery issues

As far as I have understood the balancing mechanism in England, these are factors assumed in the business analysis by market participants. They use these as input factors in their analysis whether it is to estimate the economical price for their bilateral/exchange contracts or to determine their Bid/Offer pairs to submit to the SO.

In England, SO uses Bids/Offers to estimate the cost of balancing the system which is cost of instructing the market participants to change the energy volume they are generating/consuming.

In many electricity markets, when the market operator wants to monitor the bidding behavior of the generation side, the designated market power detection procedures is based on diagnosing the Marginal Cost (MC) of generation. In the light of knowing this matter: 

  1. How the market operator/regulator treats with the issue of MC detection?

 

 

 

  1. Is it acceptable/implementable to legislate regulations to enforce the generation side disclosing the MC for the market operator or it should be the market operator that drive the MCs independently?
  2. In hydroelectric power plants how the cost of water resources is considered in the calculations of the Marginal Cost of generation?

As far as I know, the SO does not monitor the MC of the market participants.

 

 

  1. What are the major differences between the electricity trading arrangements in Iran and GB?

I would say the major difference between the two markets are in the way they are governed. The basics of power system and market operations are almost the same all around the world. The difference lies in their governance attitude not in the software or hardware they use or even the methodology used for example to solve a mixed-integer non-linear program. As a few examples I can highlight the most important ones here:

  • Panel

A set of industry experts are evaluated against specific skills, experiences and criteria and form a panel who then monitor the efficiency of the electricity market arrangements. Almost all market rules and regulations must be approved by this panel before implementation. All panel members are from businesses active in the energy sector. The government representative(s) attend the panel meetings but have no voting rights. The panel meet each month for a whole working day (around 8 hours) to discuss a broad range of issues that need to be taken care of within the market and decide/approve the best solution.

  • Customer consultation

Customer consultation is the core of all decisions in the electricity industry (not only electricity market) in England. The smallest decisions are not made without the industry being consulted as to whether or not they are happy with the arrangements which is going to be put in place. Market participants are frequently approached by the system regulator and system operator to share their opinion about a new project/plan or about a modification in the current procedures. They are asked openly to suggest their ideas if they are not content with the proposed methodology. You could not find even one new plan or modification going live without the industry being consulted and/or being invited to collaborate.

Depending on the depth and importance of the consulted on arrangements and/or modifications, the consultation period ranges from 5 working days to several months.

  • Frequent Process Reviewing

All processes are subject to constant reviewing. This is explicitly stated once the process arrangements are approved by the panel. Similar to consultation period, how often a process should be reviewed differs depending on the depth and importance of the process which is determined by the material impact it might have on the electricity market participants.

  • Supply market (retail market)

The electricity supply market was opened up to competition in England since 1998. There are hundreds of suppliers (retailers) who buy electricity from generators either bilaterally or through power exchanges or balancing market and sell to a broad range of energy consumers from households and commercial customers to large industrial businesses. Transmission and distribution companies maintain the power network as the vital infrastructure of the energy sector but they do not trade energy for profit. Energy consumers can easily choose which supplier to buy their energy from. To make this possible, as not all customers have their energy consumption metered on a half hourly basis, a robust and complex Supplier volume allocation process deploying accurate load profiles help settle the market every half hour.

 

Points to news :

Post comments

Name (required)

Email (required)

Website

your comments

So useful.thanks. Sunday, April 11, 2021 17:44
It was so useful.many thanks
Katina Saturday, July 3, 2021 09:55
Nike Outlet Store Online
Fjallraven Kanken Backpack
Nike Shoes For Men
Nike Snkrs
Jordan 6 Rings
Air Jordan 4
Yeezy
ECCO
Pandora Bracelet
Jordan 11
Pandora
Louboutin shoes
Mid Star Golden Goose
Nike Shoes For Women
Pandora Jewelry Official Site
Pandora Jewelry
NMD
Nike Shoes
Jordan Retro 11
Soccer Shoes
Jordans 11
Air Jordan 4
James Harden Shoes
Nike Factory
Cheap Jordans
Retro Jordan
Triple S Balenciaga
Nike Sale
Air Max 270
Jordan Shoes
Air Jordan 11
Red Bottoms Louboutin
Balenciaga Sneakers
GGDB Sneaker
Air Jordan Retro 10
Jordan 13s
Pandora
Nike Shoes
Jackets Moncler
Jordan 11s
Jordan 12
Moncler Jackets For Women
Yeezy
Golden Goose Shoes Women
Pandoras Jewelry
Air Force Ones Shoes
Golden Goose Sneakers Sale
Air Jordan 3 Retro
Fitflops Sale Clearance
Cheap Jordan Shoes For Men
New Jordans
Huaraches Nike
Pandora Canada
Moncler Vest
Adidas Yeezy
Jordan 11 Retro
Yeezy
Moncler Jackets
Ferragamo Outlet
Louboutin Shoes
Air Jordan
Moncler
GGDB
Pandora Jewelry
Outlet Moncler
Jordan Sneakers
Men's Nike Shoes
Jordan Retro 12
Yeezy
Retro Jordans
New Jordan 11
Air Max 90
GGDB
Jordans Sneakers
Air Max
Air Jordan 12
Adidas Yeezy
Jordan 5 Retro
Golden Goose Sneakers
Jordan Retro
Jordan 11 GYM Red
Red Bottom Shoes
Jordan 14
Air Max 98
Moncler Jacket
New Nike Shoes
Nike Website
Pandora Charms
Harden vol 1
Jordan Shoes
Nike Outlet
Jordan 11
Air Jordan Sneakers
Kyrie Irving Shoes
Nike Air Max 2018
Golden Goose Outlet
Jordan Retro 6
Air Jordan Retro 9
Jordan 5s
Air Jordan Sneakers
Pandora Rings
Nike Air Force 1 High
Jordan 4 Retro
Hermes Birkin
Jordan 3
Jordan 11s
Nike Factory
Pandora Jewelry
Golden Goose Sneakers Men
Air Jordan 5 Retro
Golden Goose Sneakers
Jordan Win Like 96
Jordan 6
Pandora Canada
Jordan Shoes
Ferragamo
Nike Shoes Outlet Store Online Shopping
Golden Gooses Sneakers
Adidas NMD R1
Jordan 11
Air Jordan
Moncler Jackets
Jordan 12 Retro
Air Max 95
Red Bottom Shoes
Air Jordan 11
Air Jordan Retro 8
Jordan 1
Pandora Ring
Fitflop Shoes
Jordan Retro
Golden Goose Sale
Jordans 4
Valentino
New Jordans
Moncler Outlet Online
William Sunday, July 18, 2021 16:12
Nike Air Force 1
Pandora Jewelry
Jordan 12
Jordan 12
Jordan 23
Air Force 1
Jordan 28
New Nikes
Nike Shoes Wholesale
Nike Air More Uptempo
Air Max
Lebron James Sneakers
Nike Outlet
Cheap Wholesale Nike Shoes And Clothing
Nike Outlet
Nike Store
Nike Foamposite
Nike Air Force 1 Mid
Nike Canada
Nike Shoes Sale
Nike Wholesale Distributors
Nike Jordan
Air Jordan 5 What The
Jordan 31
Pandora Ring
Jordans 32
Pandora Jewelry 70% off Clearance
Huaraches
Nike Factory Outlet
Adidas China
Dior Jordans
New Nikes Shoes
Nike Zoom
Wholesale Jerseys
Jordan 13
Nike Shoes Wholesale
Rings Pandora
Nike Outlet Store
Nikes
Wholesale Nike Shoes
Adidas NMD
Jordans 17
Air Jordan 13 Retro
Christian Louboutin Outlet
Jordan 11 Low
Adidas Shoes Canada
Jordan Retro
Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 V2
Nike Running Shoes For Women
Jordan 33
Jordan 22
Nike Air Force 1 Women
Jordan 30
Nike Outlet Store
Nike Sneakers
Jordan 1 Retro
Cheap Jordans
Nike Outlet Store Online Shopping
Pandora Jewelry Official Site
Wholesale Air Jordans
Nike Store
Jordan AJ 1
Cheap Jordans
Air Jordan 29
Cheap Nikes For Men
Nike Clearance Store
Wholesale Jordans From China Factory
Nike Women's Shoes
Pandora Charms
Nike Running Shoes
Air Jordan 15
Air Jordan 14
Raptors Jersey
Nike Roshe
Christian Louboutin Shoes
Air Jordan 35
Nike Outlet Online
Nike Free Rn 2019
Jordans 33
Nike Store
Jordan 34
Off White Nike
Jordan 20
Jordan 12 Retro
Air Jordan 25
Adidas Yeezy
Nike Blazers
Jordan 24
Nike Store
New Jordans
Kids Jordans
Nike Air Max 270
Jordan 27
Nike Outlet
Adidas Outlet
MLB Jerseys
Jordan 33 Shoes
Baby Jordans
Nike Black Friday Deals
Jordan 19
Foamposites
Jordan 6
Nike Shox
Wholesale Adidas
Nike Outlet Store
Air Max
Nike Running Shoes For Women
Nike Zoom Pegasus
Nike Shoes Men
Wholesale Air Jordans
Air Max 720 Flyknit
Nike Free
Nike Outlet Canada
Wholesale Adidas Shoes
Jordan 11
NHL Store
Jordan 11 Retro
Air Jordan Shoes
Adidas Outlet Store
Red Bottom Shoes Christian Louboutin
NHL Jerseys
Pandora Jewelry
Jordan 26
Cheap Shoes
Nike Air Force
Pandora CZ Charms
Jordans 16
Nike Sandals
NFL Shop Canada
Cheap NBA Jerseys
Air Max 270
Air Jordan 21
Nike Dunk
Jordan 4
Air Jordan 18
Air Jordan 11 Retro
Nike Shoes For Men
Michael Jordan Shoes
Adidas Yeezy
Huaraches Shoes
Pandora Jewelry
Wholesale Nike Shoes
Air Jordan Shoes
Nike Jordan 1
Nike Air Max Women
Wholesale Air Force Ones
Adidas Shoes For Women
Fjallraven Kanken
Pandora Bracelet Charms
Nike Huarache Men
Air Force Ones
Cheap Jordan 12
Ice Jerseys
Wholesale Cheap Jordans
Jordan 2s
Parker Tuesday, July 20, 2021 23:22
Yeezy 350
Nike Shoes
Nike Sneakers
Pandora Charms
Adidas
Pandora
Nike Canada Online
Wholesale Air Jordans
Asics Sneakers
Yeezy
Pandora Charms
Pandora Outlet Online
Pandora Store
New Nike Shoes
Adidas Official Site
Jordan 1 High
Nike Outlet
Adidas Shoes Women
Nike Air Jordans 1
Jordan 1's
Pandora Charms
Pandora Jewelry Website
Wholesale Jordan Shoes
Adidas Running Shoes
Pandora Jewelry
Nike Outlet
Adidas Shoes
Pandora Jewelry
Pandora Bracelet
Men Nike Sneakers
Pandora
Pandora Charms
Balenciaga Sale
Jordan 1 Lows
Nike Canada Online
Pandora
Pandora Charms Sale Clearance
Nike Sneakers For Women
Ferragamo
Jordan Retro 1
Moncler Jacket For Women
Moncler Outlet
Cheap Womens Adidas Shoes
Asics Running Shoes Women
Pandora Charms
Nike
Air Jordan 1
Ferragamo Belt
Asics Shoes
Cheap Nike Jordan Shoes
Moncler Coats
Salvatore Ferragamo Belt
Asics Outlet
Nike Running Shoes Sale
Balenciaga
Pandora Official Site
Wholesale Jordan Shoes
Jordan 1
Moncler Coat
Pandora Jewelry Official Site
Moncler Sale
Pandora
Balenciaga
Pandora Jewelry Official Site
Moncler Outlet
Nike Shoes Women
Pandora Charms
Balenciaga Triple S
Pandora Charms Outlet
Nike Canada
Goyard Bags
Yeezy
Pandora Jewelry
Pandora Jewelry Outlet
Pandora Jewelry Outlet
Nike Outlet Store
Adidas Canada
Adidas
Basketball Shoes
Nike Canada Online Shopping
Pandora Jewelry
NMD
Asics Kayano
Adidas Sneakers For Women
Dior Jordan 1
Shoes Nike
Jordan Ones
Pandora Jewelry 70% Off Clearance
Nike Men's Shoes
Pandora Rings
Asics
Pandora Jewelry Official Site
Pandora Charms Sale Clearance
Pandora Jewellery
Pandora Jewelry Outlet
Pandora Jewelry
Salvatore Ferragamo
Moncler Outlet
Cheap Moncler Coats
Pandora Charms
Pandora
Pandora Outlet
Nike Shoes For Women
Adidas Yeezy
Pandora Black Friday
Adidas Outlet Store
Salvatore Ferragamo Shoes
Pandora Charms
Puma Outlet
Nike Shoes Men
Pandora Rings Official Site
Pandora Charms Outlet
Nike Outlet Canada
Nike Canada
Jordan 1 Low
Pandora Jewelry
Pandora Charms
Goyard Outlet
Pandora
Pandora Charms
Pandora Charms
Nike Shoes
Air Jordan 1 Retro
Nike Air Max 270 Women's
Pandora
Mens Adidas Shoes
Adidas Canada Online Shopping
Pandora Jewelry
Adidas Sale
Asics Shoes Men
Balenciagas
Pandora Jewelry Charms
Nike Store
New Nike Shoes
Pandora
Balenciaga
Jordan Retro 1 High OG
Pandora Bracelets
Adidas Trainers Sale
Pandora Bracelets
Nike Outlet
Moncler Sale
Nike Air Jordan 1
Nike
Nike Factory
Balenciaga Shoes Women